John McGinn

Could John McGinn do a job for us?

  • Total voters
    217
Glass ankles

Glass ankles

Just doesn't shut up
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
2,362
Reaction score
3,460
Been quite impressed with this guy for Villa.
I'd take him knowing the amount of games weve got coming up.
Anyone agree/disagree?
 
Chriswwfc said:
You’d ‘take’ him?

Think it would take 30-35 mill to ‘take’ him.
Click to expand...
Yes I'd 'take' him. Like others would 'take' Felix or Ronaldo. It would be a lot more realistic to 'take' him, than 'take' them.
 
Nothing out of the ordinary about him, looks good in the championship but certainly not worth risking £25m+. We can and will do better imo
 
I like him, Grealish gets all the plaudits, but I think he’s far better. Not sure he’s top 6 quality though, which is what we’ll need to progress, so it’s a no from me.
 
He's pretty good but at the moment he'd come in and be our fourth choice central midfielder. So wouldn't be worth the money he'd cost. Let's see how he gets on in the Premier League.

I'd expect Neves, Moutinho and Dendoncker to absolutely wipe the floor with Grealish, McGinn and Hourihane.
 
Wednesbury Wolf said:
There seems to be an obsession with the Villa on here and it makes us look ridiculous.
Click to expand...
I don't think the wider footballing world really cares what goes on on Molineux Mix and even if they do, show me a club forum where there isn't threads about their rivals?
 
Decent player, but doesn't improve the squad massively so I would pass unless the price is low which it won't be.
 
Is he better than neves dendoncker or moutinho?

Nope - move on.

We don’t need another centre mid who will sit in, we need a creative player .

Wilson a much better option but did seem the occasion got to him a bit yesterday
 
Mr Wolf said:
This Villa team didn’t win the league, they weren’t chasing for auto promotion, they went on the run of a lifetime finishing 5th.

They have a few nice players & loans but they’re not that good.
Click to expand...
Exactly. They are this seasons Fulham.
 
Time will tell of the quality of Villas players. They have many loanees that I expect they will be reticent to lose any more players and will instead be looking to spend to fill the gaps. I don't know their team well enough, but I suspect next season will be ... interesting...

Regards McQuim....
Not sure he would make the squad ahead of João, Ruben, Donk and ?MGW would he???
 
Geez! The Villa are gash. Even Greasy was poor yesterday and had Derby bothered turning up for more than ten minutes, they'd have got a shoeing.
 
taking away all the other variables, hes not the type of player we'll be looking at imo
 
I actually though the standout player was Mason Bennett. I was actually thinking to myself that he could easily be converted into a RWB.
 
No thanks. Who would he replace in our midfield?
 
We could debate this until the cow's come home, but the fact is Villa have been promoted to the PL and he won't be going anywhere.
Same with Jack Grealish so let's move on.
 
Why would we even consider this, he's a good player but I can't see us improving by adding him and dropping any one of our boys. When would we use him to give our midfield a rest - early rounds of the Europa, League Cup and injuries?
Boat that.
 
Needs to learn to look up and will be booked every week in the Premier League
 
Wednesbury Wolf said:
There seems to be an obsession with the Villa on here and it makes us look ridiculous.
Click to expand...
Not obsessed with Villa. We’re just obsessed with football and need something to talk **** about until we:
  • Buy somebody
  • Release the new kit
  • Release stadium plans
  • Fixtures come out
  • Something of interest happens
In the meantime, get used to inconsequential chat and try not to get too :mad:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom