Wolf316
Just doesn't shut up
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2011
- Messages
- 22,545
- Reaction score
- 34,958
None of which are an out and out striker though.Our front 3 when all fit would be neto, Hwang and Cunha
None of which are an out and out striker though.Our front 3 when all fit would be neto, Hwang and Cunha
I think most think that this summer will be telling rather than last winter.I don't think RAN will be here after the summer if he stays fit . Anything over £40 million and they will cash in .
We don't have a strategy to push on and build a squad or team imo . It's more about player turnover and profits on them . The reinvest little on the odd up and coming players that hopefully come good and we sell for profit.
Imo that way doesn't ever get you moving forwards very far at all . Just the odd good season say top half . Then 2/3 seasons lower half of prem scrapping. Appreciate we have FFP but no other teams have sold lots of their so called better players and have a paper thin squad have they really . Everyone said in January it will bite teams and they will be selling lots of players and nothing happened .
As would I, but I get the feeling there will be more ins and outs than that.So from the current squad, I would be perfectly happy if we added one good striker and a Che Adams type.
I think with the 5 subs rule you have to have a squad of 20 plusTo keep the team fresh you have to think about the sometimes very short period of time that footballers have when they're at the top of their game.
In my opinion, there could easily be 2,3 or even 4 outgoing players from the 1st team squad most years.
It will be interesting to see if we end up with a squad of 19 or 25 players. GON's latest interview hinted that was a discussion topic. GON also stated that the bigger squad would be from lower cost players, so there is a quality of player trade off, for a bigger squad.
Then again given the large number of substitutes allowed now each game, is a larger lower individual calibre squad, with a sprinkling of top players the best option?
I think we have an option with RAN, so it's three years really.As would I, but I get the feeling there will be more ins and outs than that.
As @Madmalc said, GON may want to freshen up the squad a bit, and in line with Hobbs saying he expects at least one high profile departure, that could potentially fund a bit of a reshaping of the squad. In that sense it may actually be a necessity. I just personally hope it's not RAN, Gomes or Cunha. Those three should be indispensable.
RAN being a Mendes client with two years left on his current deal worries me quite a bit.
Didn't realise we have an extra year option, that's brilliant news.I think we have an option with RAN, so it's three years really.
I agree though, would prefer Neto to go for a big fee if we have to get one.
RAN needs games. As good as he is, would he get that at a Liverpool or United right now?I think we have an option with RAN, so it's three years really.
I agree though, would prefer Neto to go for a big fee if we have to get one.
I think numbers wise that is absolutely fine. (With the new striker, and you could also add chiquinho).Looking at the squad and assuming we kept everyone (very unlikely), where do we think we need to improve in the summer? A striker is the obvious one. Other than that, I do think our squad is quite well balanced, depending on your opinions of certain players.
GK - Sa/Bentley
RWB - Semedo/Doherty
CB - Kilman/Toti/Dawson/Bueno/Mosquera
LWB - RAN/Bueno
CM - Gomes/Lemina/Doyle/Traore
RW - Neto/Sarabia
ST - New ST/Hwang
LW - Cunha/Bellegarde
Add in a dynamic striker that can add goals, it's not looking bad is it?
That being said, wouldn't mind some upgrades to our depth options. Sa is certainly marmite as well, some weeks he's incredible and some weeks he's an utter liability.
I think the added problem now is the fact every game is on average 100 minutes long, and it's having a drastic impact on the number of injuries in the league. With the five sub rule as well, there's plenty of minutes for players in a 25 man squad to play.I think with the 5 subs rule you have to have a squad of 20 plus
Theres always going to be injuries and loss of form
A couple of youngsters is fine but you need a first team squad of minimum 18
Ok you dont need 18 quality players but certainly a few more than say 13 with a few experienced squad fillers topped off with youngsters
We cant afford to have quality long term bench warmers, but the need to rotate is vital, and most players understand this
We surely can operate in the end of contract/young talent areas of the market enough to do this
13 strikers is abit excessive but I agree.Striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, striker, goal scoring ****ing striker!
Well Sasa coming back will be like a new signing13 strikers is abit excessive but I agree.
RAN needs games. As good as he is, would he get that at a Liverpool or United right now?
haha my mate JL. love itRAN also needs a certain type of manager IMO and GON is perfect for him.
His rapid development this season reflects how he feels valued here - unlike under your mate JL.
Looked very dangerous when they were togetherNone of which are an out and out striker though.
Well Sasa coming back will be like a new signing
Nobody will want Fabio
Ok we’re up to 2 senior strikers more than we have now. Oh wait we must of loaned them out
Exactly.....People are talking about Adams as if he would be our main signing. He's clearly going to be the type of player who will get regular game time but not as a starter. We need somebody like him so the manager doesnt run our other forwards into the ground.
I would hope that your second sentence is accurate if we sign him. However l fear that in those circumstances he could well be all that we actually get.People are talking about Adams as if he would be our main signing. He's clearly going to be the type of player who will get regular game time but not as a starter. We need somebody like him so the manager doesnt run our other forwards into the ground.
Strikers are judged primarily by their goal output whatever system is being used. He is very average as you say. Can we do better? Yes.Whilst I think Che Adams is an average, lower half Premier League striker, to cite his scoring record for Scotland as an argument against signing him suggests you don't know the role Steve Clarke asks his strikers to play for Scotland. They are very much there to work their *******s off for the team, run the channels, occupy the centre halves, and drag them out of position to create space for the midfield support to get beyond them.
Since 2020, midfielders have scored more than twice the amount of goals for Scotland as the forwards have (34 goals from midfield, 16 from strikers).
He is a journeyman striker who works hard but misses far more chances than he takes. We can do so much better.adams is nowhere near as bad as you make out. 25 goals and 14 assists for a crap side. A definite improvement on Hwang as well.
Boubacar is still young and has plenty of potential. Keep and develop him.I'm not convinced it's just a numbers game in certain areas of the squad that are Gary's problems as such....he doesn't trust a few of the current squad members in my opinion Santiago Bueno, bouba and Hugo Bueno are 3 I reckon...Granted you will need to get offers but say we sold Santiago and Hugo Bueno to say fund Ahmedhodzic from Sheffield...would that give us more balance and scope in defence with.
Semedo, Kilman, Yerson , Dawson, Ahmedhodzic, Toti, Rayan, Doherty.....(Lembiksa)
Would removing 2 who the manager doesn't trust for 1 good player be better ..... obviously we won't get rid of Doherty and he just provides a bit of cover in a couple of positions...
It's similar with bouba , do we need 2 or do we need to replace bouba with someone O'Neil will want to use instead of flogging Lemina and Gomes...
I didn't know that Everton's manager played for Scotland lol.....DON'T go for. Adams. I'm a Scotland fan and he is behind Dyche in the pecking order.
The sad thing is that his previous injury record meant that the current situation was eminently predictable.Sasa is finished at the elite level of English football……. Three ACL injuries and his general fitness record must be below 40% for games in his senior career.
We should be nudging him towards retirement, as then we can get some money back against insurance.
Great lad, character good finisher so this is very hard to put down as I really wished it had worked for him.
But it was a bloody silly signing to have made as his body just isn’t made for elite sport and with our small squad approach his fitness record should have meant he couldn’t and shouldn’t have been an option as he was always more likely to be injured than fit.
That’s largely my philosophy on things; it’s why I’m happy with a smaller squad. But in a small squad (say 18 outfield players) the manager needs to trust and use them all. You often see teams with squads of 25, but the manager still mostly only uses a small core.I'm not convinced it's just a numbers game in certain areas of the squad that are Gary's problems as such....he doesn't trust a few of the current squad members in my opinion Santiago Bueno, bouba and Hugo Bueno are 3 I reckon...Granted you will need to get offers but say we sold Santiago and Hugo Bueno to say fund Ahmedhodzic from Sheffield...would that give us more balance and scope in defence with.
Semedo, Kilman, Yerson , Dawson, Ahmedhodzic, Toti, Rayan, Doherty.....(Lembiksa)
Would removing 2 who the manager doesn't trust for 1 good player be better ..... obviously we won't get rid of Doherty and he just provides a bit of cover in a couple of positions...
It's similar with bouba , do we need 2 or do we need to replace bouba with someone O'Neil will want to use instead of flogging Lemina and Gomes.....Guido Rodriguez, free transfer...
The sad thing is that his previous injury record meant that the current situation was eminently predictable.
I would get rid of Doc before Santiago or Hugo tbhI'm not convinced it's just a numbers game in certain areas of the squad that are Gary's problems as such....he doesn't trust a few of the current squad members in my opinion Santiago Bueno, bouba and Hugo Bueno are 3 I reckon...Granted you will need to get offers but say we sold Santiago and Hugo Bueno to say fund Ahmedhodzic from Sheffield...would that give us more balance and scope in defence with.
Semedo, Kilman, Yerson , Dawson, Ahmedhodzic, Toti, Rayan, Doherty.....(Lembiksa)
Would removing 2 who the manager doesn't trust for 1 good player be better ..... obviously we won't get rid of Doherty and he just provides a bit of cover in a couple of positions...
It's similar with bouba , do we need 2 or do we need to replace bouba with someone O'Neil will want to use instead of flogging Lemina and Gomes.....Guido Rodriguez, free transfer...
I like Santi. Think there is a player there.I would get rid of Doc before Santiago or Hugo tbh
He has done nothing this season and wont get better, whereas the other two have at least shown patches of decent form and could possibly improve a little
I do agree he doesnt seem to particularly trust any of them and upgrades on all would be preferable
If he does come back then the manager doesn’t want him and the player doesn’t feel “important “.The quality was there, the clubs who were looking shows he is a player with all of the talent and ability.
But they didn’t pull the trigger on a low fee for them.
He was the kind of striker who we should have signed a second striker alongside if Fabio wasn’t here like he wasn’t at the time and no Raul till after the World Cup.
Sport is just cruel, some people have the talent, the mindset and the personality to be cracking footballers, but the physiology for being able to play elite sport just isn’t there.
He is patently one of those people ask he had injuries across his body not just weak knees.
I hope he has a great support system around him as a third ACL is going to be ****ing tough to take and process about what is best long term for his health.
I saw that rumour earlier. Hopefully the days of us blindly accepting Mendes players are behind us. I'm not against using him if we want a player, but Ansu Fati isn't one if them!Nice summary of a bullet we dodged:
Ansu Fati
There's also a rumour Mendez may try to shove him our way.
Let's hope not.
If he does come back then the manager doesn’t want him and the player doesn’t feel “important “.
How does medical insurance work in football? Surely with three acls he may want to retire as he is risking a 4th , and this will surely affect him in later life.
Conroversial but I think if someone comes in with a half decent bid, I would let Hwang go.
I am not entirely convinced that his goalscoring glut earlier in the season wasn't just a “hot streak”
Generally his fitness seem to let him down a little
Some of his performances have been poor but he got away with them because he scored.
Yes but you aye getting no money for Doherty are you...I would get rid of Doc before Santiago or Hugo tbh
He has done nothing this season and wont get better, whereas the other two have at least shown patches of decent form and could possibly improve a little
I do agree he doesnt seem to particularly trust any of them and upgrades on all would be preferable