Ginger Chimp
Just doesn't shut up
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2005
- Messages
- 11,020
- Reaction score
- 8,478
Hence the need for a search party?Where is he?
Hence the need for a search party?Where is he?
Maybe if it was an option and not obligation he could prove he's worth that amount, unfortunately Chelsea won't go for that£35m is still way too much for me.
He's £20m max in my opinion.
Nobody is paying £35m for him.£35m is still way too much for me.
He's £20m max in my opinion.
Yeah I accept that, I worded it badly I don’t actually think anyone wants us to have zero cover. Some people would just like us to have more than others. My 2 cents is that I was comfortable with 4 CB’s at the end of August when we were playing a back 4. With us regularly playing 3 centre backs, I think 5 would be ideal. More pressing is another option up front, imo.It's not that people don't want the luxury of having that cover, it's weighing up the benefits of having a player out on loan playing regularly playing at a top level versus them sitting on our bench as an insurance and not continuing their development. We aren't a top six club with endless riches, so we need to develop these types of players to be future starters, or at the very least provide a substantial profit.
The reality of the situation is we're on 28 points and sitting very comfortably without even factoring in possible further points deductions to two clubs, so we can afford to take risks like this, and the Sasa and Silva loans, in order for them to get minutes and either come back to play for us, or put themselves in the shop window.
I think the club are taking a very pragmatic approach towards this transfer window, and looking forward to next season, where we can really catapult ourselves back into European competition with FFP being less of a problem.
£20m obligation with £5m in addons and I’d go for it.Loan 25m.obligation? Should we do it? If we could are there better options with prem experience.. that age. Etc.
He's a proven finisher I can say that
I just can’t see us doing loans with obligations this month. Options maybe but not obligations.£20m obligation with £5m in addons and I’d go for it.
I like Broja but not at that price.
Ask yourself why they want rid of him…..I like Broja but not at that price.
I think I read that only £30 million in total has been spent in the window so far.Can see the last couple of days of the window being a bit manic. It’s been a very, very quiet window so far but some teams need to offload players and it might happen last minute.
Perhaps I'm more glass half empty than most, but I just don't see us being good enough to sustain a push for top 7 this season. Regardless, the likelihood of Mosquera, Silva or Sasa impacting that happening is very low given how little (or no) usage they've had up to now.Yeah I accept that, I worded it badly I don’t actually think anyone wants us to have zero cover. Some people would just like us to have more than others. My 2 cents is that I was comfortable with 4 CB’s at the end of August when we were playing a back 4. With us regularly playing 3 centre backs, I think 5 would be ideal. More pressing is another option up front, imo.
I know we have to be pragmatic, but we also need to remember that if we beat Brighton tomorrow we are level on points with them, then what’s to say we couldn’t be in the hunt for Europe this season? So far we’ve actively weakened our squad imo unnecessarily, but I’m hopeful we will get one or two new faces in.
Thought so.
We did for Silva…Nobody is paying £35m for him.
If 8th gets Europe it is a tiny possibility.Perhaps I'm more glass half empty than most, but I just don't see us being good enough to sustain a push for top 7 this season. Regardless, the likelihood of Mosquera, Silva or Sasa impacting that happening is very low given how little (or no) usage they've had up to now.
Top five in a bubble of their own currently with Man City, Arsenal, Liverpool, Spurs and Villa. That leaves two spots. Do we have the quality to finish ahead of Brighton, Newcastle, West Ham, Man United and Chelsea? Maybe, I'd just expect sides like Brighton and Newcastle to improve after the injury problems they've had in the first half of the season.
Yeah, they seem to assume because they overpay for other teams players that other teams will do the same for theirs.Absolutely no way on earth will we pay £35 million for Broja. I didn’t think anyone will. Chelsea are in the waccy baccy if they actually think he’s worth £50 million
On one hand you don't want a striker that's scored in the prem, fits the profile we're looking for, and is available, but on the other hand, you want to sign some random dude from the bottom half of the championshipAsk yourself why they want rid of him…..
Move on….
Not really maths is not bizzareOn one hand you don't want a striker that's scored in the prem, fits the profile we're looking for, and is available, but on the other hand, you want to sign some random dude from the bottom half of the championship
Bizarre
I was wondering that. Seemed to be the closely of the younger CBs to a first team squad place.Will lonwijk be fit between now and the end of the season?
I am absolutely a glass half empty kinda guy, as most of my posts show! I absolutely agree it’s extremely unlikely that we end up in the European places. I just don’t like the narrative of “ah well we’ve already done better than we thought so it doesn’t matter if we loan X out or don’t get Y in”.Perhaps I'm more glass half empty than most, but I just don't see us being good enough to sustain a push for top 7 this season. Regardless, the likelihood of Mosquera, Silva or Sasa impacting that happening is very low given how little (or no) usage they've had up to now.
Top five in a bubble of their own currently with Man City, Arsenal, Liverpool, Spurs and Villa. That leaves two spots. Do we have the quality to finish ahead of Brighton, Newcastle, West Ham, Man United and Chelsea? Maybe, I'd just expect sides like Brighton and Newcastle to improve after the injury problems they've had in the first half of the season.
Do you know what would have to happen for 8th to get Europe? Is it all English clubs winning European competitions, or just some?If 8th gets Europe it is a tiny possibility.
But actually winning the cup is probably just as likely a way to get in. And that is also extremely unlikely.
I think this season is about avoiding relegation and developing the players and style/system. Anything else would be a surprise bonus.
You can say that but doesn’t make it true! 1 in 13 appearances suggests the only thing proven is he’s not all that good at finishing.He's a proven finisher I can say that
He is that good Hardie, he has been moved about and never gone for a transfer fee....Not really maths is not bizzare
Broja loan with obligation and loan fee he is not worth 30/40m
Ryan Hardie 3/4m proven scorer at champ level and worked his way up. Good work ethic
This window we don’t have the cash, hence why suggesting players from lesser teams at cheaper prices
Hardie 22 games 10 goals 4 assists in a very very poor Plymouth team…. Not as bad as many are making out……
Whittaker & Hardie goals yesterday….
What type of striker is Broja? Sasa has been loaned out because he couldn’t fit the system, Will Broja?