arctic rime
Just doesn't shut up
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2011
- Messages
- 18,099
- Reaction score
- 14,521
Not good enough as a no 2 by a country mile, dreadful last night.
That could be said about a few others . That's what happens when you have no plan and sell your so called better players and replace them with bang average Billy .
I can’t believe we didn’t sign a new number one in the summer. Bentley in the Tom King role rather than number 2 seems about right to me? Rudiculous from Fosun
That could be said about a few others . That's what happens when you have no plan and sell your so called better players and replace them with bang average Billy .
Honestly you could put Sa and Bentley in net together at the same time and I still wouldn’t feel overly confident of not conceding some calamityDidn't we also give Sa a brand new deal ?
They would jump into each other and leave a open goal. It's just a complete shambles at the moment and that lies with FosunHonestly you could put Sa and Bentley in net together at the same time and I still wouldn’t feel overly confident of not conceding some calamity
Was that ever confirmed?Didn't we also give Sa a brand new deal ?
The Tom King one for me is baffling! He is a technically atrocious keeper! Honestly he is sooooo bad for a professional.I can’t believe we didn’t sign a new number one in the summer. Bentley in the Tom King role rather than at number 2 would prob be ok. Ridiculous from Fosun
A quality keeper can literally be the difference, and we've got a choice between two who look to me like they could gift the opposition a goal at any moment. Doesn't help matters much really. Like you, replacing Sa would have been priority number one for me in the summer. At most other clubs I'm certain it would have been. We had bigger priorities though obvs.The Tom King one for me is baffling! He is a technically atrocious keeper! Honestly he is sooooo bad for a professional.
I put here a week or two back, I had to review video on him and write a report on him, after a scout put his name forward as a signing to be our clubs new number 2 who could challenge for the starting jersey.
Oooffff……. I watched his game tape and said in my report he was a waste of transfer budget and we would be better of promoting a highly rated academy keeper (he went to play in the championship) than him as he has slow reactions and terrible foot placement and speed meaning he gets casuhht out by “routine shots” needing to make a more impressive looking save or get beaten making an average shot look like a banger as it went in…..
He should have been no where near our prem club, even as third choice! He isn’t championship or league 1 starting keeper standard if you are club thinking of pushing for league honours.
Now hear me out on this one, as even though he was awful last night…….
Bentley is a decent back up keeper, but he looked rusty as all heck last night, the first and second goals were the movement and reactions of a keeper who hasn’t seen active match play in some time. It is more exposing for a keeper, as if they are a second out in reactions or sloppy with footwork as not match sharp like an outfielder can be and some were last night, they concede a goal but the midfielder gets away unpunished on the score board.
Jose Sa, is a relegation quality keeper in terms of technique and GK IQ, he had one good season. Then Video people got to review him to give a sheet on him to their strikers and ball players and he is exposed most weeks, if he doesn’t expose himself with his terribly erratic thinking. He should have been upgraded in the summer as priority one! As a team fighting relegation need a good striker every bit as much as a striker. for a relegation side a quality keeper is worth their weight in goldz
I can’t believe we didn’t sign a new number one in the summer. Bentley in the Tom King role rather than at number 2 would prob be ok. Ridiculous from Fosun
I should probably bow to your obviously superior knowledge on keepers. But I do have a few questions on this.The Tom King one for me is baffling! He is a technically atrocious keeper! Honestly he is sooooo bad for a professional.
I put here a week or two back, I had to review video on him and write a report on him, after a scout put his name forward as a signing to be our clubs new number 2 who could challenge for the starting jersey.
Oooffff……. I watched his game tape and said in my report he was a waste of transfer budget and we would be better of promoting a highly rated academy keeper (he went to play in the championship) than him as he has slow reactions and terrible foot placement and speed meaning he gets casuhht out by “routine shots” needing to make a more impressive looking save or get beaten making an average shot look like a banger as it went in…..
He should have been no where near our prem club, even as third choice! He isn’t championship or league 1 starting keeper standard if you are club thinking of pushing for league honours.
Now hear me out on this one, as even though he was awful last night…….
Bentley is a decent back up keeper, but he looked rusty as all heck last night, the first and second goals were the movement and reactions of a keeper who hasn’t seen active match play in some time. It is more exposing for a keeper, as if they are a second out in reactions or sloppy with footwork as not match sharp like an outfielder can be and some were last night, they concede a goal but the midfielder gets away unpunished on the score board.
Jose Sa, is a relegation quality keeper in terms of technique and GK IQ, he had one good season. Then Video people got to review him to give a sheet on him to their strikers and ball players and he is exposed most weeks, if he doesn’t expose himself with his terribly erratic thinking. He should have been upgraded in the summer as priority one! As a team fighting relegation need a good striker every bit as much as a striker. for a relegation side a quality keeper is worth their weight in goldz
Having seen King for 10 mins against Rennes the answer is truly atrocious. Think 6' fridge going down in stages.....Honestly you could put Sa and Bentley in net together at the same time and I still wouldn’t feel overly confident of not conceding some calamity
Linked in the summer with Kelleher and Ariola, whilst Henderson and possibly even Bounou were available lol. Stuck with these two clowns instead. How bad must Tom King be?
Was that ever confirmed?
The last four/five months have been a nightmare **** storm of epic proportions. Five years work undone.I feel this last part could be copied, pasted, and tagged on to rather a lot of sentences that describe the club’s recent actions.
Yeah, you are bang on with Bentley, reserve games were a good standard for players to get fitness back but in a far less demanding environment. I actually think the development of young talent after 21 is stunted because of the move away, but it has helped others so it is swings and roundabouts lol.I should probably bow to your obviously superior knowledge on keepers. But I do have a few questions on this.
Is this a problem with the modern world of no reserve football, 10 years ago I imagine Bentley would have had a game every week so he wouldn't look so rusty.
How many goals would you say we have we actually conceded this season due to Sa's actual 'goalkeeping' as opposed to his distribution? I'm sure an expert could find fault with lots of things, but to the untrained eye only the Estupinan one sticks out, and even there he's not made an awful mistake.
That could be said about a few others . That's what happens when you have no plan and sell your so called better players and replace them with bang average Billy .
Cheers.Yeah, you are bang on with Bentley, reserve games were a good standard for players to get fitness back but in a far less demanding environment. I actually think the development of young talent after 21 is stunted because of the move away, but it has helped others so it is swings and roundabouts lol.
Without re-watching the goals mate, I can’t say off hand and to throw a number out would be really disingenuous. But you do have to factor in the “distribution” error goals
sadly. GK’s from a young age are drilled into multiple throw types, kick types and ground passing to help them pick the right one at the right time. This glaring whole in his game is more than just his ground work, he can only kick well using the running volley type swiping kick, you will have noticed after the first season where it was a good weapon, teams rush to put blockers in his path or bump him when he claims a cross. This then clearly rattles him or panics him as the kicks are then more wayward and look how often he reacts and shoves/barges the attacker……
Look at his penalty record and how it is the same style of pen everytime! He rushes, cannot get there and smashes the striker. Look at how many times the striker wasn’t going to score even if he collects the ball. Or how many times he rushes, slides and misses the ball. It is why the drilled pass forward behind defenders towards him as a through ball is used so often, his decision making is very very poor and because he has slow and sloppy footwork, he cannot control his body weight and change direction well. Hence all the missed claims and pens and why it is a much used tactic against us. The vardy pen last season was the perfect and clear example of the massive weakness he has in decision making, control of movement and footwork.
The hole in his game is too happily excused here as “the curse of the modern keeper” needing to pay from the back. The issue with Sa, is that all of his distribution from throws or hand started kicks is quite weak.
Sam any mock meslier on here, but Sa is actually technically a weaker keeper than him.
The lad is 29, been around the portugal squad for many many years and never got a cap!
Others have in that time, Rui got dropped for the keeper who got to the champions league final with Marcal, so that is another excuse that doesn’t wash that Rui has held the shirt and no one else has had a chance.
To be fair, Bentley is a solid number 2 for most prem clubs. But you can just see he has not match sharpness.Cheers.
The rushing out to strikers in 1 on 1s has certainly been a weakness, I'm really hoping the new coach is going to improve him there. I think he did get a bit better, but he was certainly vulnerable to 'clever' strikers like Vardy, who would make the contact whether he was truly reckless or not.
For my money every team blocks keepers trying to counter attack from corners, it's a bit ironic that his worst distribution error of the season (Robertson's goal) was exactly that sort of kick and I don't think he got impeded, he either realised what a bad idea it was before he actually kicked it, or just messed it up.
Of all the problems we have currently I don't think Sa is a major one, judging by last night Sa getting injured would be a massive one (but maybe that's harsh and Bentley isn't as bad as it looked - I was probably harsh on him for the 3rd, from behind the goal it did look quite a wicked strike).
I laughed in my seat at that one where he flopped down and only just got to a tame daisy cutter……Having seen King for 10 mins against Rennes the answer is truly atrocious. Think 6' fridge going down in stages.....
He did well at Old Trafford though, made a bad mistake on about 95 minutes v Everton, by Arsenal everyone had knocked off! So I'm not sure there's enough to hang him on yet. (Trying to be optimistic unless @berwickwolf starts worrying for my well-being! )To be honest, you knew after Everton Bentley was nowhere near it.
It's why I have always backed Sa and found the calls for Bentley baffling.
The Everton game was his chance to impress and he cost us a win in the last minute. That showed he can't deal with the pressure, as well as showing he has mistakes in him. It was his big opportunity, and he blew it.
Last night, under new management, he has the next big opportunity, and he blew it.
It's character as much as technical - and this guy was captain and is part of the leadership group!!!
Sa is crap with the ball at his feet but is levels above the other keepers we have. The simple thing that GON needs to do is to adapt the style so he’s not having to play with the ball. It’s not rocket science.To be honest, you knew after Everton Bentley was nowhere near it.
It's why I have always backed Sa and found the calls for Bentley baffling.
The Everton game was his chance to impress and he cost us a win in the last minute. That showed he can't deal with the pressure, as well as showing he has mistakes in him. It was his big opportunity, and he blew it.
Last night, under new management, he has the next big opportunity, and he blew it.
It's character as much as technical - and this guy was captain and is part of the leadership group!!!
Wyatt Earp couldn't do worse than Bentley or King....I just wonder if Mary Earps would come to Molineux.
Couldn’t be worse than the clowns we have now in goal.
Would improve our shooting!Wyatt Earp couldn't do worse than Bentley or King....
Wyatt Earp couldn't do worse than Bentley or King....
Despite being dead lol...Would improve our shooting!
To GO it is though…..Sa is crap with the ball at his feet but is levels above the other keepers we have. The simple thing that GON needs to do is to adapt the style so he’s not having to play with the ball. It’s not rocket science.
It comes back to him having a pre conceived idea without having the players to carry it out. If your keeper can’t kick you work around that until you get a keeper who can kick.To GO it is though…..