JadeWolf
Official Noddy pre match thread starter.
- Joined
- Aug 16, 2017
- Messages
- 28,452
- Reaction score
- 58,710
Rui had a poor season last year (and looks to have made a few rickets this year). He might be on the way down but has been a top keeper for an extended period. I have been pleasantly surprised by Sa but it is notable that those (e.g. the Mix's Portuguese members) who have watched him previously are surprised at his form this season. He is having an exceptional season but it may very well be a one off. Much more evidence is required to justify your final assertion.Notice that the Rui worshippers from last season are conspicuous by their absence. Jose can have mad moments, but he is a far better all round keeper
Who other than podence would have seen him play before?but it is notable that those (e.g. the Mix's Portuguese members) who have watched him previously are surprised at his form this season.
Well, 30 odd games is a pretty long 'one off'. How many games does he need to have played to justify my final assertion in your opinion? I was never particularly impressed with Rui and his statistical record according those on here who looked at it (not me) suggested he was one of the poorest keepers in the PL. I never thought he was much of an improvement on John Ruddy if I'm honest. Didn't ever command his area and too often let in really soft goals.Rui had a poor season last year (and looks to have made a few rickets this year). He might be on the way down but has been a top keeper for an extended period. I have been pleasantly surprised by Sa but it is notable that those (e.g. the Mix's Portuguese members) who have watched him previously are surprised at his form this season. He is having an exceptional season but it may very well be a one off. Much more evidence is required to justify your final assertion.
I may be wrong but l believe that the statistical issue you mention in your third sentence was solely true for Rui's third season at Wolves. That was in rather stark difference to the first two seasons. To say that Rui was little better than Ruddy, at least until last season, is farcical.Well, 30 odd games is a pretty long 'one off'. How many games does he need to have played to justify my final assertion in your opinion? I was never particularly impressed with Rui and his statistical record according those on here who looked at it (not me) suggested he was one of the poorest keepers in the PL. I never thought he was much of an improvement on John Ruddy if I'm honest. Didn't ever command his area and too often let in really soft goals.
He didn't always play in Greece! He played in Portuguese football for both Maritimo and Porto. There are Portuguese Mixers who have commented that he has exceeded their expectations.Who other than podence would have seen him play before?
Farcical? Balls. Perfectly tenable. Rui was a bit too prone to give soft goals away when he played for us, whatever season you are looking at. I think he was living on past glories. Ruddy is unjustly maligned by too many on here.I may be wrong but l believe that the statistical issue you mention in your third sentence was solely true for Rui's third season at Wolves. That was in rather stark difference to the first two seasons. To say that Rui was little better than Ruddy, at least until last season, is farcical.
Given that Ruddy, who l rate incidentally, is the King of soft goals conceded that comment is a tad ironic.Farcical? Balls. Perfectly tenable. Rui was a bit too prone to give soft goals away when he played for us, whatever season you are looking at. I think he was living on past glories. Ruddy is unjustly maligned by too many on here.
But better at saving penalties than Sa or Patricio?Given that Ruddy, who l rate incidentally, is the King of soft goals conceded that comment is a tad ironic.
Who other than podence would have seen him play before?
Ah yes those two games would have given them a good chance to watch himDidn't he play twice against us for Olympiakos?
noBut better at saving penalties than Sa or Patricio?
Well excluding Man City and Liverpool players that is they have just announced. Ah **** it he would have got in anyway in front of Ederson and Allison. Haha.He has just been put into the team of the year on Saturday Social too.